45 observations

Patterns

These are observations. They are not proof of any cause or link. Each one lists what is NOT known.

independent discovery Writing was invented more than once Writing appears in Mesopotamia (about 3400 to 3200 BCE) and Egypt (about 3250 BCE) at about the same time. independent discovery Farming began in many places on its own Farming began in the Middle East, China, Mexico and New Guinea, among other regions. recurring behavior Huge monuments in places that never met Göbekli Tepe (Turkey) was built about 9500 BCE. repeated unexplained situation Huge eruptions and mass extinctions line up in time The end-Permian extinction (about 252 Mya) overlaps with the Siberian Traps eruptions. recurring behavior Life spreads into new forms after big extinctions After the Great Dying, new groups of animals took over in the sea and on land. Dinosaurs rose after the end-Triassic extinction. recurring behavior Living things have changed Earth's air and climate Oxygen-making microbes raised oxygen in the air (about 2.4 Bya). repeated unexplained situation One tool design for over a million years The Acheulean handaxe appears about 1.76 million years ago in Africa. repeated unexplained situation Art and symbols in widely separated places Beads and a drawing from South Africa are about 75,000 to 73,000 years old. repeated unexplained situation Big animals vanish as people arrive Many large animals died out in Australia, the Americas and elsewhere over tens of thousands of years. independent discovery The wheel appears in two regions at about the same time A picture of a wheeled wagon appears in Poland about 3500 to 3300 BCE. repeated unexplained situation Several societies weakened around 2200 BCE Egypt's Old Kingdom ended (about 2181 BCE). recurring behavior Written laws appear in several unconnected societies The Code of Ur-Nammu (Sumer, about 2100 BCE) is the oldest surviving law code. repeated unexplained situation Major thinkers in China, Greece and India in the same centuries Confucius taught in China (traditionally 551 to 479 BCE). repeated unexplained situation Big epidemics reached empires along army and trade routes The Antonine Plague (165 to 180 CE) appeared among Roman soldiers besieging Seleucia in Mesopotamia and spread through the empire. It is probably smallpox, possibly measles. independent discovery Zero was worked out in more than one place Babylonian scribes used a mark for an empty place in their base-60 numbers, as a placeholder. repeated unexplained situation Dry spells are suggested whenever big societies weakened Egypt's Old Kingdom ended about 2181 BCE. Low Nile floods and drought are suspected. recurring behavior Accidents and surprises behind big finds The afterglow of the Big Bang (1964): a hiss in a radio antenna. recurring behavior When a strong ruler dies, the realm often splits or fights Alexander the Great died in 323 BCE without an adult heir. His generals fought for about 40 years (the Wars of the Successors) and split the empire into rival kingdoms. debated theory Debated theory: Chinese dynasties rise and fall in a repeating cycle Label: debated theory, not an established law. debated theory Debated theory: new rulers come from the edges and lose their unity in a few generations Label: debated theory, not proof. recurring behavior Governments under strain water down their money Roman emperors cut the silver in their coins step by step to pay for armies. The main silver coin (the antoninianus) fell from about 50% silver to under 5% by about 270 CE, during the Crisis of the Third Century. recurring behavior Big inventions took centuries to cross Eurasia Paper: made in China by the 2nd century BCE (improved by Cai Lun in 105 CE). It reached the Islamic world in the 8th century (Baghdad by about 793) and Europe only by the 11th century. independent discovery The same idea is found by different people at about the same time Historians call this 'multiple discovery'. The sociologist Robert K. Merton argued it is the normal pattern in science, not the exception. repeated unexplained situation Big eruptions, cold years, and hunger or unrest soon after 43 BCE: Okmok volcano in Alaska erupted. Ice cores and models show unusually cold years after it. A 2020 study links this to famine in Egypt and hardship in Rome as the Republic ended and the Ptolemaic kingdom weakened. recurring behavior Unrest often follows food shortages and high food prices About 1157 BCE: Egypt's royal tomb builders at Deir el-Medina stopped work because their grain rations were late. It is the first recorded strike. recurring behavior Two rivals wear each other out, then an outsider wins Greece: Athens and Sparta fought the Peloponnesian War (431 to 404 BCE). Sparta, then Thebes, led Greece briefly, and constant fighting weakened them all. Philip II of Macedon defeated Athens and Thebes at Chaeronea in 338 BCE. repeated unexplained situation An old empire is not more likely to fall than a young one A 2011 study by Samuel Arbesman looked at 41 empires from 3000 BCE to 600 CE (using data gathered by Rein Taagepera). debated theory Debated theory: things that have lasted a long time tend to keep lasting Label: debated theory (a rule of thumb), not proof. recurring behavior Watching the sky to keep time, and to read omens Egypt's 365-day calendar marked its new year by the rising of the star Sirius, which came near the start of the Nile flood. repeated unexplained situation Outbreaks of strange behaviour that spread without a germ 1374: hundreds of people in towns along the Rhine were seized by a compulsion to dance for hours or days. recurring behavior Mathematics worked out long before anyone found a use for it Greek geometers studied the curves called conic sections (Apollonius, about 200 BCE). About 1,800 years later, Kepler (1609) found that planets move in one of them, the ellipse. debated theory Debated theory: science changes in sudden revolutions Label: debated theory. debated theory Debated theory: history moves in 80-to-100-year generational cycles Label: debated theory. Many scholars reject it. debated theory Debated theory: economies move in long waves of about 50 years Label: debated theory. Most mainstream economists do not accept it. debated theory Debated theory: farming states swing between growth and crisis over centuries Label: debated theory. debated theory Debated theory: empires stretch further than they can pay for, then pull back Label: debated theory. repeated legend Founder legends: the baby set adrift who grows up to rule A later legend says Sargon of Akkad was put in a reed basket sealed with pitch and set on the Euphrates, then found and raised by a water-drawer. recurring behavior When a ruler adopts a faith, it spreads across the realm and beyond India: after the Kalinga War (about 261 BCE), Ashoka promoted Buddhist moral teaching on rocks and pillars across his empire. Tradition says he sent monks abroad, including to Sri Lanka. recurring behavior People move or raid when the climate turns harsh Indus cities (from about 1900 BCE): people moved east and south into smaller villages. A weaker monsoon is one suggested cause. recurring behavior Prices soar on hope and excitement, then crash 1636 to 1637: 'tulip mania' in the Netherlands, when prices of rare tulip bulbs rose very high and then collapsed. recurring behavior Rulers borrow heavily, fail to repay, and bankers fall 1340s: the great Florentine banks of the Peruzzi (1343) and Bardi (1346) failed, partly because loans to kings, including Edward III of England, were not repaid. recurring behavior Science predicted things before anyone found them Halley used Newton's laws to predict his comet's return, and it came back in 1758. recurring behavior Some cures worked long before anyone knew why Scurvy: in 1753 James Lind reported that citrus fruit cured sailors. Vitamins were named only in 1912, and vitamin C was identified in the 1930s. recurring behavior Astrology lasted alongside astronomy (as belief) Label: this is about what people believed. Astrology is a belief, not a science. recurring behavior A new instrument brought a burst of discoveries The electric battery: Humphry Davy used it to isolate sodium and potassium (1807), then calcium, barium and others (1808).