recurring behavior
Unrest often follows food shortages and high food prices
These are observations. They are not proof of any cause or link. Each one lists what is NOT known.
What is observed
- About 1157 BCE: Egypt's royal tomb builders at Deir el-Medina stopped work because their grain rations were late. It is the first recorded strike.
- 184 CE: the Yellow Turban revolt in Han China came after years of floods, droughts, locusts, famine and disease, on top of heavy taxes.
- 1789: in France, after poor harvests, the price of bread rose sharply (one estimate is 88% in that year) while real wages fell. The Bastille fell that July.
- 2008 and 2010 to 2011: a 2011 study found that waves of food riots, and the Arab Spring (which began in December 2010), came when world food prices peaked.
- 1848: revolutions swept Europe after potato blight (from 1845) and poor grain harvests (1846) caused a food crisis. Economic historians call this crisis one of the most immediate causes.
- 1917: Russia's February Revolution began when women in Petrograd protested over bread shortages.
- China, 11 to 18 CE: a great Yellow River flood brought famine and refugees, then peasant revolts such as the Red Eyebrows, which helped end Wang Mang's Xin dynasty.
- The Yellow Turban page says the main revolt was put down by 185 AD, and that resisting areas were not fully subdued until 205 AD.
- It records disease outbreaks in 171, 173, 179, 182, and 185 AD, and says one suggested cause is the Antonine Plague moving along the Silk Road.
- It says Zhang Jue proclaimed the rebellion on 4 March, with the slogan that the Azure Sky was already dead and the Yellow Sky would soon rise.
What is not known
- Hunger alone rarely explains a revolt. Anger at rulers, taxes, ideas and leaders also matter.
- Many famines did not lead to revolts. The 2011 study used world prices, not the prices people actually paid locally.
Linked entries
Year 29 of Ramesses III, about 1157 BCE Deir el-Medina strike Royal tomb builders stop work because their grain rations are late. 184 to 205 CE (main uprising 184 to 185) Yellow Turban Rebellion A huge peasant revolt weakens the Han dynasty. 1789 French Revolution begins The Bastille falls; Lavoisier lists chemical elements; Washington becomes president. 1848 Revolutions of 1848; Communist Manifesto; gold in California Seneca Falls women's rights meeting. 1917 Russian Revolution; Balfour Declaration; US enters war The Bolsheviks take power. 2010 Haiti earthquake; Arab Spring begins; Deepwater Horizon; synthetic cell Over 100,000 die in Haiti; Venter's lab makes a cell with synthetic DNA. 2011 Arab Spring Protests topple rulers in Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Yemen; Syria descends into civil war. 11 CE Yellow River flood In 11 CE the Yellow River floods badly in north China. 18 CE Red Eyebrows In 18 CE Fan Chong starts a peasant revolt in Shandong against Wang Mang, using Mount Tai as his base.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Yellow Turban Rebellion
- Wikipedia: Causes of the French Revolution
- arXiv: The food crises and political instability in North Africa and the Middle East (Lagi, Bertrand and Bar-Yam, 2011)
- Wikipedia: Revolutions of 1848
- Smithsonian Magazine: Russia's February Revolution was led by women on the march