Patterns

recurring behavior

Governments under strain water down their money

These are observations. They are not proof of any cause or link. Each one lists what is NOT known.

What is observed

  • Roman emperors cut the silver in their coins step by step to pay for armies. The main silver coin (the antoninianus) fell from about 50% silver to under 5% by about 270 CE, during the Crisis of the Third Century.
  • One study found that prices did not rise as fast as the silver fell until after Aurelian's reform of 274, when the coins lost most of their buying power by 301.
  • England's Great Debasement (1544 to 1551): Henry VIII cut the silver in coins from 92.5% to as low as 25% to pay for wars. Foreign traders refused the coins; Elizabeth I restored the coinage in 1560.
  • Yuan China (1350s): the government printed huge amounts of paper money to pay for civil wars. Prices soared, the last series of notes (1350) was widely refused, and the Ming drove the Yuan out in 1368.
  • 1923: Weimar Germany printed money to cover its spending and debts. Prices doubled every few days, savings were wiped out, and a new currency, the Rentenmark, ended it in November 1923.
  • The antoninianus page says that even when the coin was introduced, its silver was worth only 1.5 denarii.
  • It says the XXI mark is still debated, and is thought to mean a 20 to 1 silver ratio, about 4.76 percent silver.

What is not known

  • Debasement usually came after the trouble started (war, plague, revolt). It is a sign of strain, not proven to be the cause of collapse.
  • How much prices rose, and why, is debated for Rome.

Linked entries