Patterns

recurring behavior

Astrology lasted alongside astronomy (as belief)

These are observations. They are not proof of any cause or link. Each one lists what is NOT known.

What is observed

  • Label: this is about what people believed. Astrology is a belief, not a science.
  • China, 6th century BCE: court astrologers predicted the fates of states and rulers from fires, eclipses and new stars (533, 532, 511 BCE). Some of these 'predictions' may have been written after the events.
  • Doubt was there early too: in 524 BCE the statesman Zichan refused an astrologer's demand for treasure, saying 'The way of Heaven is far; the way of people is near.' In 521 BCE a Lu official called eclipses at the solstices and equinoxes natural.
  • Tang China (729): the Kaiyuan Zhanjing mixed real star catalogues and Indian maths with omens.
  • Europe and America: almanacs kept printing planetary forecasts in the 1700s, even after Newton.
  • Modern times: Theosophists and Alan Leo popularised horoscopes (1875 to 1890s); the first newspaper horoscope column appeared in 1930; in 1997 the Heaven's Gate cult tied the Hale-Bopp comet to a spaceship, and 39 members died.
  • The astrology page says a form of astrology was practised in Mesopotamia in the Old Babylonian period, about 1800 BCE.
  • It says the Venus tablet of Ammisaduqa is thought to have been compiled in Babylon around 1700 BCE.
  • The same page says astrology has been recognized as pseudoscience since the 18th century. This atlas keeps it as historical belief, not as science.

What is not known

  • Why astrology survives every advance in astronomy is debated (comfort, entertainment, tradition). Tests have not found that it predicts anything.

Linked entries

533 BCE Fire in Chen A fire burns in Chen; a Zheng astrologer, Pi Zao, predicts that Chen will be restored in five years. 532 BCE Star and omen A new star appears in the Wunü lodge; the Zheng astrologer Pi Zao predicts the ruler of Jin will die on a wuzi day in the seventh month, and the Chunqiu records Duke Ping of Jin dying on that day. 511 BCE Solar eclipse The Spring and Autumn Annals record a solar eclipse seen in the state of Lu. A Jin minister asks the astrologer Shi Mo about a dream and the eclipse. 524 BCE Zichan on omens Fires break out in Song, Wey, Chen and Zheng on the same day; when an astrologer demands treasures to prevent more fires, Zichan refuses. 521 BCE Solar eclipse The Spring and Autumn Annals record a solar eclipse seen in the state of Lu. A Lu official says eclipses at solstices and equinoxes are not disasters. by 729 CE Kaiyuan Zhanjing By 729 a team led by Gautama Siddha, an Indian astronomer born in Chang'an, finishes the Kaiyuan Zhanjing, a huge book of astrology and astronomy. 1252 Alfonsine Tables begun Alfonso X of Castile has astronomers prepare tables of planet positions, used in Europe for 300 years. 1757 Almanacs keep astrology popular Popular almanacs such as Poor Richard's still printed planetary forecasts. 1875 Theosophical Society founded An occult movement; Theosophists such as Alan Leo later shaped modern horoscope astrology. 1890 Alan Leo's astrology magazine Alan Leo popularises horoscope astrology in Britain. 1930 First newspaper horoscope column R. H. Naylor's astrology column in the Sunday Express (about Princess Margaret's birth) starts the modern horoscope page. 1910 Halley's Comet panic; Mexican Revolution People bought 'comet pills' fearing tail gas; Japan annexes Korea. 1997 Hale-Bopp comet and the Heaven's Gate deaths A cult links the comet to a spaceship; 39 members die.