Patterns

debated theory

Debated theory: Chinese dynasties rise and fall in a repeating cycle

These are observations. They are not proof of any cause or link. Each one lists what is NOT known.

What is observed

  • Label: debated theory, not an established law.
  • Traditional Chinese history describes a 'dynastic cycle': a new dynasty wins the Mandate of Heaven, grows rich, then becomes corrupt, faces disasters and revolts, loses the Mandate and is replaced.
  • The Zhou used the Mandate of Heaven idea to justify overthrowing the Shang (about 1046 BCE).
  • The pattern is often read into the Qin (fell 206 BCE after revolts), the Han (Wang Mang's break, the Yellow Turban revolt of 184, the end in 220), and the Tang (the An Lushan revolt of 755, the end in 907).
  • Periods of division were followed by reunification, for example the Sui in 589 after almost 400 years of division.
  • Later turns of the wheel in this atlas: the Song lost the north to the Jin (1127) and fell to the Mongol Yuan (1279); the Ming drove out the Yuan (1368); rebels took Beijing and the Manchu Qing took power (1644); the White Lotus Rebellion (1796 to 1804) shook the Qing.
  • The last turn: the Taiping (from 1850) and Boxer (1900) risings shook the Qing, and the revolution of 1911 ended China's emperor system in 1912. The People's Republic was proclaimed in 1949.
  • Late Tang: the rebel Huang Chao proclaimed himself emperor (881). After the Tang fell (907) and a period of division, the Song reunited most of China (960).
  • Signs of decline read into the Han: a flood and famine helped topple Wang Mang (11 to 23 CE); later Emperor Ling sold government posts (178), not long before the Yellow Turban revolt.
  • The dynastic cycle page says Mencius, in the Warring States period, championed the Mandate of Heaven explanation.
  • It says the Qin rejected that model, and that Han historians such as Ban Gu took it up again in the Book of Han.
  • It says that in 1945 Huang Yanpei asked Mao Zedong how he would end China's dynastic cycles, and that Mao answered that the new path was democracy, so long as the public kept oversight of the government.

What is not known

  • Many historians, such as John K. Fairbank, say the cycle is only a surface political pattern that hides deeper economic, social and technical change.
  • The cycle was partly written into history by later court historians, who described each dynasty's rise and fall in moral terms.
  • It does not predict when a dynasty will fall.
  • Whether modern China fits the old cycle at all is a political question as much as a historical one; Chinese leaders themselves have discussed it.

Linked entries

about 1046 BCE Zhou conquer Shang The Zhou overthrow the Shang and introduce the 'Mandate of Heaven'. 771 BCE (the capital moved in 770 BCE) Zhou capital moves east Invaders sack the Zhou capital and the king is killed. The Zhou move east and lose real power. 221 BCE First emperor One ruler governs a unified China for the first time. 209 BCE Dazexiang uprising Conscripts late for duty rise against Qin, starting the revolts that end the dynasty. 202 BCE Han dynasty founded Liu Bang beats Xiang Yu at Gaixia and becomes the first Han emperor. 9 to 25 CE Wang Mang and Eastern Han A usurper's short dynasty splits Han rule into Western and Eastern halves. 184 to 205 CE (main uprising 184 to 185) Yellow Turban Rebellion A huge peasant revolt weakens the Han dynasty. 220 CE Han ends The Han ends. China splits into three kingdoms for decades. 589 to 618 CE Sui dynasty After nearly 400 years of division, China is one again. 618 CE (the dynasty lasted to 907) Tang dynasty Li Yuan founds the Tang dynasty, often seen as a golden age. 755 to 763 CE An Lushan Rebellion A general's revolt nearly ends the Tang and weakens it for good. 907 CE Tang ends The Tang falls and China splits into many states. 256 BCE Zhou dynasty ends Qin takes the last Zhou lands, ending a royal line that had lasted about 790 years. 1127 Jingkang incident: Song loses the north The Jin take Kaifeng and capture two Song emperors; the Song rebuild in the south. 1279 Battle of Yamen: Song dynasty ends The last Song forces are destroyed at sea; China is ruled entirely by the Yuan. 1271 Kublai founds the Yuan dynasty; Marco Polo sets out Kublai Khan proclaims the Yuan dynasty; the Polos begin their journey east. 1368 The Ming dynasty Zhu Yuanzhang becomes the Hongwu Emperor; the Mongols are driven from Beijing. 1644 Fall of the Ming; Qing enter Beijing Rebels take Beijing, the last Ming emperor hangs himself, and the Manchus take power. 1797 White Lotus Rebellion; Cavendish weighs the Earth Henry Cavendish measures Earth's density (published 1798). 1850 Taiping Rebellion begins; Clausius's thermodynamics Hong Xiuquan's movement starts in south China. 1900 Boxer Rebellion; Planck's quantum; Mendel rediscovered Max Planck proposes energy comes in quanta; Zeppelin flies; Freud's dream book. 1911 Atomic nucleus; superconductivity; China's revolution Rutherford finds the nucleus; Amundsen reaches the South Pole. 1949 People's Republic of China; Soviet bomb; NATO Mao proclaims the PRC. 881 CE Huang Chao The rebel Huang Chao, a former salt trader, proclaims himself emperor of a new Qi dynasty. 960 CE Song dynasty The general Zhao Kuangyin takes the throne and founds the Song dynasty, which reunites most of China. 11 CE Yellow River flood In 11 CE the Yellow River floods badly in north China. 18 CE Red Eyebrows In 18 CE Fan Chong starts a peasant revolt in Shandong against Wang Mang, using Mount Tai as his base. 178 CE Offices for sale Emperor Ling of Han begins selling official posts for money, which spreads corruption.