Patterns

debated theory

Debated theory: things that have lasted a long time tend to keep lasting

These are observations. They are not proof of any cause or link. Each one lists what is NOT known.

What is observed

  • Label: debated theory (a rule of thumb), not proof.
  • The 'Lindy effect' says that for things that do not wear out, like ideas, books or institutions, the longer they have lasted, the longer they are likely to last. Nassim Nicholas Taleb made the idea popular in 2012.
  • Long survivors in this atlas: the Julian calendar (45 BCE) was used in Europe until 1582 and is still used by some churches; the Chinese emperor system lasted from 221 BCE to 1912; the eastern Roman empire lasted about 1,000 years after 476; Buddhism, Christianity and Islam have outlasted every empire that hosted them at the start.
  • Other examples: the University of al-Qarawiyyin in Morocco (founded 859) still operates; the Japanese temple builder Kongō Gumi ran as a family firm from 578 until 2006, and still exists inside another company.
  • Also in this atlas: the University of Bologna (traditionally 1088) is the oldest university still running; the Gregorian calendar (1582) is now the main civil calendar in most of the world; the Dujiangyan irrigation system in Sichuan (about 256 BCE) is still in use.
  • Iceland's Althing (930) is often called the world's oldest surviving parliament.
  • The Lindy effect page says Benoit Mandelbrot, in The Fractal Geometry of Nature (1982), used the same name for a different idea.
  • It says human beings are perishable, with life expectancy at birth in developed countries about 80 years, so the Lindy effect does not apply to an individual human lifespan.

What is not known

  • We only see the survivors. The many old things that did end are easy to forget.
  • It conflicts with a study of empires, which found that an empire's age did not change its chance of falling (see the pattern on empire lifespans).
  • Long life is no guarantee: the Holy Roman Empire ended in 1806 after about 1,000 years.

Linked entries