Patterns

recurring behavior

Big inventions took centuries to cross Eurasia

These are observations. They are not proof of any cause or link. Each one lists what is NOT known.

What is observed

  • Paper: made in China by the 2nd century BCE (improved by Cai Lun in 105 CE). It reached the Islamic world in the 8th century (Baghdad by about 793) and Europe only by the 11th century.
  • Printing: the oldest dated printed book is China's Diamond Sutra (868). Printing with a press began in Europe about 1450, nearly 600 years later.
  • Gunpowder: described in Chinese texts in the 9th century, with written formulas by 1044. The first European description is Roger Bacon's, in 1267.
  • Cast iron: made in China from about the 8th to 5th centuries BCE. Europe made it regularly only in the Middle Ages.
  • Once guns appeared in the 13th century, they spread across Eurasia in about 50 years, much faster than paper or printing.
  • Movable type: Bi Sheng made clay movable type in China in the 1040s. Gutenberg's metal movable type came about 400 years later (about 1450).
  • Numbers: Indian rules for zero (628) and the Hindu-Arabic digits passed through the Islamic world; Fibonacci's book (1202) taught them to Europeans, and merchants switched only slowly.
  • A Spanish manuscript of 976 (the Codex Vigilanus) already shows Hindu-Arabic digits, more than 200 years before Fibonacci, yet Europe was slow to adopt them.
  • Some secrets travelled by smuggling or memory: monks brought silkworm eggs to Byzantium (553), and Samuel Slater rebuilt British spinning machines in the US from memory (1790).
  • The history-of-paper page says the oldest surviving paper fragment was found at Fangmatan in Gansu and is dated to 179 to 141 BCE.
  • It says Jonathan Bloom calls the story of Chinese prisoners bringing papermaking to Central Asia unlikely to be factual, and that paper was already used in Samarkand decades before 751 CE.
  • It says paper spread to Vietnam in the 3rd century, to Korea in the 4th century, and to Japan in the 5th century.

What is not known

  • The exact routes are often unknown. The famous story that Chinese prisoners brought paper-making to Samarkand after the Battle of Talas (751) is doubted by scholars.
  • Some ideas may have been invented again rather than copied. Why some inventions spread fast and others slowly is not settled.

Linked entries