independent discovery
Writing was invented more than once
These are observations. They are not proof of any cause or link. Each one lists what is NOT known.
What is observed
- Writing appears in Mesopotamia (about 3400 to 3200 BCE) and Egypt (about 3250 BCE) at about the same time.
- Writing appears again in China (the oldest well-known examples, oracle bones, are about 1250 BCE) and in Mesoamerica (about 600 BCE, though some claim earlier).
- Each region developed its own signs.
- The history-of-writing page says four inventions are the ones most often counted as independent: Mesopotamia about 3400 to 3100 BCE, Egypt about 3250 BCE, China before about 1250 BCE, and Mesoamerica before about 1 CE.
- The same page says early differences in structure and style are why scholars argue that Egyptian hieroglyphs and Sumerian cuneiform grew up separately, and that no final decision has been made on where hieroglyphs began.
- Signs on shells at Jiahu in China, from the 7th millennium BCE, are not treated by most archaeologists as true writing. The Indus signs, about 2600 to 2000 BCE, are still unread, and scholars do not agree that they are writing.
- The history-of-writing page says Sumerian cuneiform and Egyptian hieroglyphs both grew out of proto-writing between 3400 and 3100 BC, and that the earliest coherent texts in both are about 2600 BC.
- The same page says glyphs found at Abydos, dated between 3400 and 3200 BC, have been used against the idea that writing spread from Mesopotamia to Egypt.
- It says there is no evidence of contact between the Shang dynasty, about 1600 to 1050 BC, and the literate Near East, and that Chinese characters work differently from cuneiform and hieroglyphs.
What is not known
- Whether Egypt's writing was inspired by Sumer's idea is debated.
- The China and Mesoamerica dates here are well-known examples, not necessarily the first marks.
- Wikipedia dates the Mesoamerican case as before about 1 CE. That is a wider window than the 'about 600 BCE' example already stored above.
- The history-of-writing page dates the earliest inscriptions it can identify as Maya to the 3rd century BC, and the earliest that can be read to 199 AD. That is later than the stored example of about 600 BCE.
Linked entries
about 3400 to 3200 BCE Writing in Sumer Counting marks on clay tablets grow into the first writing. about 3250 BCE Earliest Egyptian writing Tiny labels with signs are found in a royal tomb before the first pharaohs. about 1250 to 1050 BCE Oracle bones Questions carved on shells and bones become the oldest large body of Chinese writing.