Patterns

repeated unexplained situation

Big eruptions, cold years, and hunger or unrest soon after

These are observations. They are not proof of any cause or link. Each one lists what is NOT known.

What is observed

  • 43 BCE: Okmok volcano in Alaska erupted. Ice cores and models show unusually cold years after it. A 2020 study links this to famine in Egypt and hardship in Rome as the Republic ended and the Ptolemaic kingdom weakened.
  • Ptolemaic Egypt (305 to 30 BCE): a 2017 study found that years after big eruptions had weaker Nile floods, and that revolts often began in those years.
  • 536 CE: a huge eruption, followed by more in 540 and 547, began a long cold period (the 'Late Antique Little Ice Age', 536 to about 660). Researchers link it to crop failures before the Plague of Justinian (541).
  • 1815: Tambora (Indonesia), the largest eruption in recorded history, erupted. 1816 became the 'Year Without a Summer': crops failed across the northern world, food prices rose, and there were food riots in England.
  • 1257: Samalas on Lombok (Indonesia), one of the largest eruptions in thousands of years, cooled the climate. Famines and crop failures followed in Europe and elsewhere, though their scale is debated.
  • 1783: Iceland's Laki fissure poisoned grass and killed over half the livestock. The famine that followed killed at least a fifth of Iceland's people.
  • Modern eruptions still cool the climate: Pinatubo (Philippines) cooled the world in 1991.
  • The 1257 Samalas page says the flows destroyed Pamatan, capital of a kingdom on Lombok.
  • It says the eruption was matched to the ice-core sulfate spike only in 2013, using the Babad Lombok, a palm-leaf manuscript written by people who saw it.
  • It says 1257 is the likeliest year, and that 1258 is also possible.

What is not known

  • The studies say eruptions added a shock to societies that already had problems. They do not prove eruptions caused revolts or collapses.
  • Dating ancient eruptions precisely is hard, and many eruptions had no clear effect on people.

Linked entries