debated theory
Debated theory: new rulers come from the edges and lose their unity in a few generations
These are observations. They are not proof of any cause or link. Each one lists what is NOT known.
What is observed
- Label: debated theory, not proof.
- Ibn Khaldun, a North African scholar, wrote in his Muqaddimah (1377) that group unity ('asabiyya') is strongest in tough peoples on the edges of empires.
- He said such groups conquer the settled centre, grow soft and divided, and are replaced by a new group from the edges. He wrote that a dynasty rarely lasts beyond three generations of about 40 years each.
- Cases that fit the outline: the Zhou came from the west to overthrow the Shang; Macedon, on the edge of the Greek world, took over Greece (338 BCE); Arab armies from Arabia took Syria, Egypt and Persia (633 to 651); the Umayyads ruled for about 90 years before the Abbasids replaced them (750).
- Later cases that fit the outline: the Mongols united on the steppe (1206) and conquered settled empires; the Ottomans began as a small frontier state in Anatolia (about 1299); the Manchus from beyond the Great Wall took China (1644).
- The asabiyyah page says the idea was already familiar before Islam, and that in the Muqaddimah it is the basic force of history, pure only in its nomadic form.
- The same page says the new rulers are at first considered barbarians beside the rulers they replace.
What is not known
- Choosing cases that fit is easy. Many dynasties lasted far longer than 120 years.
- 'Group unity' is hard to measure, so the theory is hard to test.
Linked entries
about 1046 BCE Zhou conquer Shang The Zhou overthrow the Shang and introduce the 'Mandate of Heaven'. 338 BCE Battle of Chaeronea Philip II of Macedon beats Athens and Thebes and becomes master of Greece. 633 to 651 CE Early Arab conquests Arab armies take Syria, Egypt and Persia in less than twenty years. 661 to 750 CE Umayyad Caliphate The caliphate becomes a hereditary empire ruled from Damascus. 750 to 762 CE Abbasids and Baghdad A new dynasty builds a new capital, Baghdad. 1206 Temujin becomes Genghis Khan; Delhi Sultanate founded A great assembly names Temujin ruler of all Mongols; Qutb ud-Din Aibak founds the Delhi Sultanate. 1299 Osman I and the Ottoman beginnings Osman's small state in north-west Anatolia, the start of the Ottoman Empire, dates from about 1299. 1644 Fall of the Ming; Qing enter Beijing Rebels take Beijing, the last Ming emperor hangs himself, and the Manchus take power.