Patterns

debated theory

Debated theory: new rulers come from the edges and lose their unity in a few generations

These are observations. They are not proof of any cause or link. Each one lists what is NOT known.

What is observed

  • Label: debated theory, not proof.
  • Ibn Khaldun, a North African scholar, wrote in his Muqaddimah (1377) that group unity ('asabiyya') is strongest in tough peoples on the edges of empires.
  • He said such groups conquer the settled centre, grow soft and divided, and are replaced by a new group from the edges. He wrote that a dynasty rarely lasts beyond three generations of about 40 years each.
  • Cases that fit the outline: the Zhou came from the west to overthrow the Shang; Macedon, on the edge of the Greek world, took over Greece (338 BCE); Arab armies from Arabia took Syria, Egypt and Persia (633 to 651); the Umayyads ruled for about 90 years before the Abbasids replaced them (750).
  • Later cases that fit the outline: the Mongols united on the steppe (1206) and conquered settled empires; the Ottomans began as a small frontier state in Anatolia (about 1299); the Manchus from beyond the Great Wall took China (1644).
  • The asabiyyah page says the idea was already familiar before Islam, and that in the Muqaddimah it is the basic force of history, pure only in its nomadic form.
  • The same page says the new rulers are at first considered barbarians beside the rulers they replace.

What is not known

  • Choosing cases that fit is easy. Many dynasties lasted far longer than 120 years.
  • 'Group unity' is hard to measure, so the theory is hard to test.

Linked entries