debated theory
Debated theory: science changes in sudden revolutions
These are observations. They are not proof of any cause or link. Each one lists what is NOT known.
What is observed
- Label: debated theory.
- In 1962 Thomas Kuhn argued that scientists usually work inside a shared picture (a 'paradigm'). Puzzles that do not fit build up until a crisis, and a new picture replaces the old one.
- Kuhn's examples include the Sun-centred universe of Copernicus (1543), Newton's physics (1687), Lavoisier's chemistry of oxygen, and Einstein's relativity. In this atlas the Copernican change took over a century, through Kepler (1609) and Galileo's trial (1633), to Newton.
- Modern cases in this atlas: evolution by natural selection (1858); Einstein's relativity (1905 and 1915), tested by the 1919 eclipse; Wegener's drifting continents (1912), widely rejected at first, then accepted in the 1960s as plate tectonics after seafloor magnetic stripes were explained (1963).
- Smaller turns: scientists accepted that rocks fall from space after a meteorite shower at L'Aigle (1803); Koch's anthrax work (1876) helped establish germ theory; evolution was openly fought over at Oxford (1860); Wegener's book on drifting continents (1915) was rejected for decades.
- The Stanford Encyclopedia page on Thomas Kuhn says his account is that science enjoys periods of stable growth punctuated by revisionary revolutions.
- The same page says Kuhn added an incommensurability thesis: theories from differing periods suffer from deep kinds of failure of comparability.
- It says Kuhn denied that a gain in puzzle-solving power is evidence of getting nearer to the truth.
What is not known
- Philosophers and historians dispute how sudden and how complete such changes really are.
- Kuhn's claim that rival pictures cannot be fairly compared ('incommensurability') is especially debated.
Linked entries
1543 Copernicus and Vesalius publish Copernicus's On the Revolutions puts the Sun at the centre; Vesalius's Fabrica shows the body from dissection; the Portuguese reach Japan. 1609 Kepler's laws; Galileo's telescope Kepler shows planets move in ellipses; Galileo builds a telescope and studies the Moon. 1633 Galileo's trial The Inquisition forces Galileo to recant and places him under house arrest. 1687 Newton's Principia Newton sets out the laws of motion and universal gravitation; the Parthenon is blown up in a siege. 1858 First transatlantic cable; Darwin and Wallace paper A telegraph cable briefly works across the Atlantic. 1905 Einstein's miracle year; Russian revolution of 1905 Special relativity, E = mc squared, light quanta. 1912 Titanic sinks; continental drift; Cepheid yardstick Wegener proposes drifting continents; Leavitt's star law measures distances. 1915 Armenian genocide; general relativity; Gallipoli Einstein completes general relativity. 1919 Eclipse confirms Einstein; Versailles; Amritsar Eddington measures starlight bending; British troops kill hundreds at Amritsar. 1962 Kuhn's Structure of Scientific Revolutions Thomas Kuhn argues science changes through 'paradigm shifts'; his idea is still debated. 1963 Seafloor stripes support plate tectonics Vine and Matthews explain magnetic stripes on the seafloor; by the late 1960s most geologists accept moving plates. 1803 Cerium discovered; meteorites accepted A shower of stones at L'Aigle convinces scientists rocks fall from space. 1876 Koch proves anthrax is caused by a germ First disease tied to a specific bacterium. 1860 Oxford evolution debate Huxley and Wilberforce argue over Darwin. 1915 Wegener's Origin of Continents and Oceans His book on continental drift.