recurring behavior
When a strong ruler dies, the realm often splits or fights
These are observations. They are not proof of any cause or link. Each one lists what is NOT known.
What is observed
- Alexander the Great died in 323 BCE without an adult heir. His generals fought for about 40 years (the Wars of the Successors) and split the empire into rival kingdoms.
- Qin Shi Huang, China's first emperor, died in 210 BCE. A court plot put a weak son on the throne, revolts broke out (Chen Sheng, 209 BCE), and the Qin fell by 206 BCE.
- After Charlemagne's son Louis the Pious died in 840, his sons fought a civil war. The Treaty of Verdun (843) divided the empire into three.
- In Egypt, palace plots struck at the moment of succession: Amenemhat I was murdered (about 1962 BCE), and a queen plotted to put her son on the throne after killing Ramesses III (about 1155 BCE).
- Medieval cases now in this atlas: after Vladimir of Kiev died (1015) his sons fought over the throne; Cnut's North Sea empire split when he died (1035); Hungary had succession disputes after Stephen I (1038); William the Conqueror's sons divided Normandy and England (1087); Saladin's lands were split among relatives (1193).
- By Kublai Khan's death (1294) the Mongol Empire had become four separate khanates.
- Early modern cases: Portugal's succession crisis (1383); the War of the Spanish Succession (from 1701); the last great Mughal emperor died in 1707; Prussia invaded Silesia when Maria Theresa inherited Austria (1740).
- Tang China (626): Prince Li Shimin killed two brothers, including the crown prince, in the Xuanwu Gate Incident, and soon became Emperor Taizong.
- China's Spring and Autumn period: when Duke Zhuang of Lu died (662 BCE) his heir was killed within months; when Duke Huan of Qi died (643 BCE) his sons fought over the throne.
- The Franks: Clovis's kingdom was split among four sons (511); Louis the Pious's succession plan (817) led to family wars, the battle of Fontenoy (841) and the final split of Charlemagne's empire (888).
- The Wars of the Diadochi page says Alexander died on 10 June 323 BC, and that the empire had no clear successor. It names his half-brother Arrhidaeus, his unborn son Alexander IV, and a reputed illegitimate son, Heracles.
- It says the battle of Ipsus in 301 BC left the Ptolemies and Seleucids as the two main Hellenistic dynasties, and that at Corupedium in 281 BC Seleucus I was the only original successor still alive.
- The Wars of the Diadochi page says one faction was led by Meleager, who supported Alexander's half-brother Arrhidaeus.
What is not known
- Many strong rulers were followed by calm handovers. Nobody has counted how often a split follows versus how often it does not.
- Each case also had its own causes (money, war, rivals), so the death of the ruler is a trigger, not a full explanation.
- The Wars of the Diadochi page says that fifty years after Alexander's death some sort of order was restored. A stored line says the generals fought for about 40 years.
Linked entries
336 to 323 BCE Alexander the Great A Macedonian king conquers the Persian Empire. Greek culture spreads from Egypt to India. 221 BCE First emperor One ruler governs a unified China for the first time. 209 BCE Dazexiang uprising Conscripts late for duty rise against Qin, starting the revolts that end the dynasty. 202 BCE Han dynasty founded Liu Bang beats Xiang Yu at Gaixia and becomes the first Han emperor. 25 December 800 CE Charlemagne The king of the Franks is crowned Emperor in Rome. 843 CE Treaty of Verdun Charlemagne's empire is split among his grandsons. about 1962 BCE (Amenemhat I's Year 30) Story of Sinuhe The old king is killed in a palace plot; the famous Story of Sinuhe opens with this event. about 1155 BCE Harem conspiracy A queen's plot kills Ramesses III, but her son does not take the throne. 1015 Death of Vladimir the Great The ruler who made Kievan Rus' Christian dies, and his sons fight over the throne. 1035 Cnut dies; William becomes duke of Normandy Cnut's North Sea empire splits; a boy, William (later the Conqueror), becomes duke of Normandy. 1038 Stephen I of Hungary dies Hungary's first king, who made the country Christian, dies; disputes over succession follow. 1087 William the Conqueror dies William dies in France; his sons divide Normandy and England. 1193 Saladin dies Saladin dies of fever in Damascus; his lands are split among relatives. 1294 Kublai Khan dies The Mongol empire is by now four separate khanates. 1383 Portuguese succession crisis Portugal fights to stay independent of Castile. 1707 Great Britain formed; Aurangzeb dies; Mount Fuji erupts England and Scotland unite; the last great Mughal emperor dies; Fuji's last eruption. 1701 Tull's seed drill; War of the Spanish Succession Jethro Tull's drill sows seeds in rows; Europe goes to war over Spain's throne; Prussia becomes a kingdom. 1740 War of the Austrian Succession Frederick the Great invades Silesia when Maria Theresa inherits. 2 July 626 CE Xuanwu Gate Prince Li Shimin kills his two brothers in a palace coup and soon becomes Emperor Taizong of Tang. 662 BCE Lu succession crisis Duke Zhuang of Lu dies; his heir Ziban is killed within months, and Prince Qingfu flees to Qi. 643 BCE Duke Huan dies Duke Huan of Qi, the first hegemon, dies; his sons fight over the throne. 511 CE Clovis dies Clovis, the first king to unite the Franks, dies on 27 November 511 in Paris. 817 CE Ordinatio Imperii After a wooden gallery collapses under him at Aachen, Louis the Pious issues the Ordinatio Imperii, making his son Lothair co-emperor and main heir. 841 CE Battle of Fontenoy On 25 June 841 Charles the Bald and Louis the German defeat their brother Lothair at Fontenoy, the biggest battle of the Carolingian civil war. 888 CE Empire splits After Charles the Fat dies on 13 January 888, the Frankish empire breaks into separate kingdoms; Odo, Count of Paris, becomes king of West Francia.