independent discovery
The same idea is found by different people at about the same time
These are observations. They are not proof of any cause or link. Each one lists what is NOT known.
What is observed
- Historians call this 'multiple discovery'. The sociologist Robert K. Merton argued it is the normal pattern in science, not the exception.
- Ancient cases in this atlas: writing (Sumer, Egypt, China, Mesoamerica), farming in many regions, zero (Babylon, the Maya, India) and possibly the wheel.
- Calculus: Newton worked it out about 1666; Leibniz published his own version in 1684. Oxygen: Scheele found it before Priestley (1774), and Lavoisier explained it. Evolution by natural selection: Darwin and Wallace reached it separately and were presented together in 1858.
- Year length: Chinese astronomers measured the year as 365.2425 days (1280), the same value Europe's Gregorian calendar used three centuries later (1582).
- The telescope (1608): Hans Lipperhey and Jacob Metius applied for Dutch patents within weeks of each other; the patent was refused partly because the device was easy to copy.
- Logarithms: John Napier published in 1614; Jost Bürgi worked out his own tables independently and published them in 1620.
- The Leyden jar (1745), the first store of electric charge: Ewald von Kleist and Pieter van Musschenbroek each found it by accident.
- Telephone: Alexander Graham Bell's patent application and Elisha Gray's notice of a similar invention were filed at the US patent office on the same day (14 February 1876).
- Heredity: Mendel's laws (1865) were ignored, then 'rediscovered' in 1900 by Hugo de Vries, Carl Correns and Erich von Tschermak, traditionally said to have worked independently.
- More cases: Lomonosov (1756) and Lavoisier (1774) each showed that mass is conserved in reactions; Kant (1755) and Laplace (1796) separately proposed that the solar system formed from a spinning cloud; chloroform was made independently in several countries in 1831; in 1964 several teams proposed the Higgs mechanism; Weinberg and Salam each unified two forces (1967 to 1968).
- The multiple-discovery page says Robert K. Merton held that a second discovery is not always simultaneous. Someone can find again, years later and without knowing it, what another person already found.
- It says that in 1712 the Royal Society published a report, written by Newton himself, that gave Newton priority in calculus.
- It says a joint Darwin-Wallace paper was read at the Linnean Society on 1 July 1858, and that neither the reading nor the publication drew interest.
What is not known
- Why it happens is debated. One idea is that once the needed tools and knowledge exist, several people are likely to take the next step.
- Some 'independent' discoveries may have been influenced by contact that left no record.
- How independent the three 1900 'rediscoverers' of Mendel really were is debated.
Linked entries
about 3400 to 3200 BCE Writing in Sumer Counting marks on clay tablets grow into the first writing. about 3250 BCE Earliest Egyptian writing Tiny labels with signs are found in a royal tomb before the first pharaohs. about 1250 to 1050 BCE Oracle bones Questions carved on shells and bones become the oldest large body of Chinese writing. about 10,000 to 8000 BCE Farming begins People in the Middle East start growing wheat and barley and herding animals. about 7000 to 2000 BCE (dates vary by place) Farming elsewhere China, Mexico, New Guinea and other regions develop farming on their own. about 3500 to 3150 BCE The wheel Wheeled carts appear in Europe and Mesopotamia at about the same time. about 1800 BCE (Old Babylonian period, about 2000 to 1600 BCE) Babylonian mathematics Scribes use a base-60 number system and solve problems with right triangles. 6 July 292 CE Tikal Stela 29 The oldest surviving Maya Long Count date in the lowlands. 628 CE Brahmagupta's zero An Indian mathematician treats zero as a number with rules. 1280 Guo Shoujing's Shoushi calendar Chinese astronomers measure the year as 365.2425 days, the same value as the later Gregorian calendar. 1582 The Gregorian calendar Pope Gregory XIII drops 10 days to fix the calendar; Nobunaga is killed. 1608 The telescope is invented Hans Lipperhey asks the Dutch for a patent on a spyglass; Quebec is founded. 1614 Napier's logarithms John Napier publishes logarithms, making big calculations much easier. 1666 Newton's wonder year; Great Fire of London At home during the plague, Newton develops calculus, studies light and thinks about gravity; fire destroys central London. 1684 Leibniz publishes calculus Leibniz's first paper on differential calculus appears. 1745 Leyden jar stores electricity; Jacobite rising The first capacitor stores electric charge; Bonnie Prince Charlie lands in Scotland. 1774 Priestley isolates oxygen Joseph Priestley makes oxygen by heating mercury oxide (Scheele had found it earlier). 1858 First transatlantic cable; Darwin and Wallace paper A telegraph cable briefly works across the Atlantic. 1876 Telephone; Battle of Little Bighorn; Otto engine Bell patents the telephone; Otto's four-stroke engine. 1865 Mendel's heredity; Lincoln killed; antiseptic surgery Mendel's peas; Lister uses carbolic acid; US 13th Amendment. 1900 Boxer Rebellion; Planck's quantum; Mendel rediscovered Max Planck proposes energy comes in quanta; Zeppelin flies; Freud's dream book. 1756 Lomonosov tests mass conservation Mikhail Lomonosov heats metals in sealed vessels. 1774 Lavoisier's tin experiment He shows mass is conserved in reactions. 1755 Kant's nebular hypothesis Kant suggests the solar system formed from a spinning cloud. 1796 Lithography invented; Laplace's nebular theory Alois Senefelder prints from stone. 1831 Chloroform discovered Made independently in several countries. 1964 Higgs mechanism proposed Higgs, Englert and others explain mass. 1967 Electroweak theory Weinberg and Salam unify forces (1967 to 1968).