Patterns

recurring behavior

Prices soar on hope and excitement, then crash

These are observations. They are not proof of any cause or link. Each one lists what is NOT known.

What is observed

  • 1636 to 1637: 'tulip mania' in the Netherlands, when prices of rare tulip bulbs rose very high and then collapsed.
  • 1720: the South Sea Company in London and the Mississippi Company in Paris. Share prices shot up and then crashed in the same year.
  • The economist Charles Kindleberger (Manias, Panics, and Crashes, 1978) described a repeating sequence: a new opportunity, easy credit, a rush of buyers, then panic and crash.
  • 2000: shares of internet companies peaked in March and then collapsed; the Nasdaq index lost about three-quarters of its value by 2002.
  • 1873: a boom in railway building and speculation collapsed, setting off the Panic of 1873 and a long depression.
  • 1929: the Wall Street Crash began the Great Depression. 2008: the collapse of Lehman Brothers set off a global financial crisis after a housing boom.
  • The tulip mania page dates the major acceleration to 1634 and the collapse to February 1637.
  • It says a contemporary satire places the start of the crash on 3 February in Haarlem, when an auctioneer could not find buyers even after lowering the price.
  • It says some modern economists offer rational explanations for the rise and fall, rather than calling it a speculative mania.

What is not known

  • How big tulip mania really was is disputed. Historians such as Anne Goldgar argue it involved a small group of traders and was exaggerated by later writers.
  • Economists disagree about whether bubbles can be spotted before they burst.

Linked entries