Patterns

debated theory

Debated theory: empires stretch further than they can pay for, then pull back

These are observations. They are not proof of any cause or link. Each one lists what is NOT known.

What is observed

  • Label: debated theory.
  • Historian Paul Kennedy (1987) argued that great powers decline when their military commitments grow faster than their economies. He called this 'imperial overstretch'.
  • Rome reached its largest size under Trajan (about 117 CE). His successor Hadrian, soon after taking power in 117, gave up the new eastern provinces and went back to the Euphrates border.
  • China's Sui dynasty spent heavily on the Grand Canal and on failed wars against Goguryeo (612 to 614). Revolts followed, and the dynasty fell in 618.
  • Alexander's army refused to go further into India (326 BCE).
  • The Hadrian page says he abandoned Trajan's gains in Mesopotamia, Assyria, Armenia, and parts of Dacia.
  • The page on Kennedy's book says he predicted that if China's economic development kept up, China would become a great power within decades.

What is not known

  • Critics say the theory leaves out politics, leaders and choices, and makes decline sound inevitable.
  • Pulling back (as Hadrian did) can be a sign of good sense, not of decline.

Linked entries