debated theory
Debated theory: economies move in long waves of about 50 years
These are observations. They are not proof of any cause or link. Each one lists what is NOT known.
What is observed
- Label: debated theory. Most mainstream economists do not accept it.
- In the 1920s the Soviet economist Nikolai Kondratiev described long waves of rising and falling prices and output of about 45 to 60 years.
- Later writers, such as Joseph Schumpeter, linked the waves to clusters of new technologies (for example steam, railways, electricity).
- One common list of technology waves starts them in 1771 (the Industrial Revolution and Arkwright's mills), 1829 (steam and railways), 1875 (steel and heavy engineering), 1908 (oil, electricity, cars and mass production; the Model T) and 1971 (information technology; the microprocessor).
- Supporters point to long slumps such as the depression after the Panic of 1873 and the Great Depression after 1929 as the downswings. The economist Carlota Perez (2002) argued that each wave has a 'frenzy' phase of speculation.
- The links here show what the theory claims, not proof that a cycle exists.
- The Kondratiev wave page says Jacob van Gelderen in 1913 and Salomon de Wolff in 1924 argued for 50- to 60-year cycles before Kondratiev's 1926 book.
- It gives Kondratiev's own 19th-century dating as 1790 to 1849, with a turning point in 1815, then 1850 to 1896, with a turning point in 1873, and a new cycle supposed to start in 1896.
- It says critics agree the theory may be seeing a pattern that is not there, and it names that apophenia.
What is not known
- Critics find no convincing regular cycle in real output; the waves may be a result of how the data are smoothed.
- With only a few waves since about 1780, there is too little data to test the idea well.
Linked entries
1769 Arkwright's water frame; Cugnot's steam cart Spinning is powered by water mills; a steam vehicle is built in France; Cook maps New Zealand. 1830 July Revolution; Liverpool-Manchester railway; Lyell's geology France invades Algeria; US Indian Removal Act. 1873 Panic of 1873; Maxwell's Treatise A long depression begins. 1908 Tunguska blast; Model T; Haber's ammonia A space rock flattens Siberian forest; Ford's car; ammonia from air. 1929 Wall Street Crash; Hubble's law The Great Depression begins; galaxies move away faster the farther they are. 1971 Bangladesh war; microprocessor; Mars orbit Intel 4004; Mariner 9 orbits Mars.