repeated unexplained situation
An old empire is not more likely to fall than a young one
These are observations. They are not proof of any cause or link. Each one lists what is NOT known.
What is observed
- A 2011 study by Samuel Arbesman looked at 41 empires from 3000 BCE to 600 CE (using data gathered by Rein Taagepera).
- Their lifetimes fit a pattern where the chance of falling in any century did not depend on how old the empire was. The average lifetime was about 220 years.
- Biological species and companies show a similar pattern.
- Empires in this atlas range from short (the Qin, 221 to 206 BCE) to long (the Han, about four centuries).
- At the long end: the Zhou royal line lasted about 790 years (to 256 BCE), and the eastern Roman empire lasted until the Ottomans took Constantinople in 1453.
- Modern endings in this atlas: the Holy Roman Empire was dissolved in 1806 after about 1,000 years; the Ottoman state, begun about 1299, gave way to the Republic of Turkey in 1923; the Soviet Union lasted 69 years (1922 to 1991).
What is not known
- The result rests on a small set of 41 empires, and how to date an empire's start and end is a matter of judgement.
- The pattern still needs testing on larger and newer datasets.
- It describes the numbers; it does not explain why empires fall.
- Arbesman writes that an exponential distribution is memoryless, and also that the fitness of these systems is not inherently independent of time, especially for species.
Linked entries
about 2334 BCE (Sargon's reign is dated about 2334 to 2279 BCE) Sargon of Akkad A ruler joins many Sumerian cities and lands into one large empire. about 2154 BCE Akkad falls The first empire breaks apart. A dry spell and invaders are both suspected. 221 BCE First emperor One ruler governs a unified China for the first time. 202 BCE Han dynasty founded Liu Bang beats Xiang Yu at Gaixia and becomes the first Han emperor. 220 CE Han ends The Han ends. China splits into three kingdoms for decades. 911 to 609 BCE Neo-Assyrian empire Assyria grows into the largest empire the world had yet seen, ruling from the Gulf to Egypt at its peak. 612 BCE Fall of Nineveh Babylonians and Medes destroy Assyria's capital. 4 September 476 CE Western Rome falls The last emperor in the west is removed. The eastern empire lives on for 1,000 years. 907 CE Tang ends The Tang falls and China splits into many states. 256 BCE Zhou dynasty ends Qin takes the last Zhou lands, ending a royal line that had lasted about 790 years. 29 May 1453 Fall of Constantinople; end of the Hundred Years' War Mehmed II takes Constantinople with huge cannons, ending the Byzantine Empire; France wins at Castillon. 1279 Battle of Yamen: Song dynasty ends The last Song forces are destroyed at sea; China is ruled entirely by the Yuan. 1644 Fall of the Ming; Qing enter Beijing Rebels take Beijing, the last Ming emperor hangs himself, and the Manchus take power. 1806 Holy Roman Empire ends Napoleon dissolves it after 1,000 years. 1923 Great Kanto earthquake; Turkey founded Over 100,000 die in Tokyo area. 1922 USSR formed; Tutankhamun found; Mussolini Howard Carter opens the tomb. 1991 USSR dissolves; Gulf War; first website; Yugoslav wars Pinatubo cools the world.