Patterns

debated theory

Debated theory: farming states swing between growth and crisis over centuries

These are observations. They are not proof of any cause or link. Each one lists what is NOT known.

What is observed

  • Label: debated theory.
  • Peter Turchin and Sergey Nefedov (Secular Cycles, 2009) argued that farming states go through cycles of two to three centuries: population grows, wages fall, the number of people competing for elite posts grows, and the state falls into crisis and civil war.
  • Their cases include England, France, Russia and Rome: the Roman Republic cycle (about 350 to 30 BCE) and the Principate cycle (30 BCE to 285 CE).
  • In this atlas, the Roman Republic's crises (the Gracchi, 133 BCE; the Social War, 91 BCE; Caesar's civil war) and the Crisis of the Third Century fall in the later, troubled part of their Republican cycle, and the Crisis of the Third Century falls at the end of their Principate cycle.
  • Their England cases are the Plantagenet cycle (1150 to 1485) and the Tudor-Stuart cycle (1485 to 1730). The Wars of the Roses (from 1455) and the English Civil War (from 1642) fall inside them.
  • A 2023 paper already cited here, Georgescu in PLOS ONE, says the three predictions of structural-demographic theory for industrialized societies are not supported by US data.
  • The same paper says the theory has empirical support for pre-industrial societies, and that the largest share of US wage variance from 1980 to 2016 is explained by automation, not by labor oversupply.

What is not known

  • Critics question how 'too many elites' is measured and whether the theory works outside its chosen cases.
  • A 2023 test using modern data found little support for it.

Linked entries