Patterns

recurring behavior

Rulers borrow heavily, fail to repay, and bankers fall

These are observations. They are not proof of any cause or link. Each one lists what is NOT known.

What is observed

  • 1340s: the great Florentine banks of the Peruzzi (1343) and Bardi (1346) failed, partly because loans to kings, including Edward III of England, were not repaid.
  • Spain defaulted on its debts six times between 1557 and 1647, starting under Philip II, and seven more times in the 19th century.
  • Economists Carmen Reinhart and Kenneth Rogoff (This Time Is Different, 2009) found that 'serial default', the same country defaulting again and again, is common across eight centuries.
  • The Reinhart and Rogoff working paper of March 2008 says serial default is a nearly universal phenomenon as countries move from emerging markets to advanced economies.
  • The same paper says major default episodes are typically spaced some years or decades apart, which creates an illusion that this time is different.
  • It says default often comes with other crises, including inflation, exchange-rate crashes, banking crises, and currency debasements.

What is not known

  • How much Edward III's unpaid loans caused the Florentine collapse is debated; the banks had other problems too.
  • Some 'defaults', such as Philip II's in 1557, were partly forced reschedulings rather than total refusals to pay.

Linked entries