repeated unexplained situation
Major thinkers in China, Greece and India in the same centuries
These are observations. They are not proof of any cause or link. Each one lists what is NOT known.
What is observed
- Confucius taught in China (traditionally 551 to 479 BCE).
- Socrates taught in Athens and died in 399 BCE.
- The Buddha taught in northern India in about the 5th century BCE (his dates are debated).
- The philosopher Karl Jaspers called this period the 'Axial Age' in 1949.
- The Axial Age page defines the period as broad changes in religious and philosophical thought from about the 8th to the 3rd century BCE.
- It says Jaspers included Persia, India, China, the Levant, and the Greco-Roman world, and that he saw no obvious mixing between those cultures.
- The same page says the historical validity of the Axial Age is disputed, including for lack of a shared cause, lack of a sharp break with earlier and later periods, and the exclusion of figures such as Jesus, Muhammad, and Akhenaten.
What is not known
- Whether this is a real pattern or only looks like one is debated. The regions covered a wide span of time.
- No contact between these regions at that time is known to have caused it.
Linked entries
lived about 563 to 483 BCE or about 480 to 400 BCE The Buddha Siddhartha Gautama teaches in the Ganges valley; Buddhism begins. traditionally 551 to 479 BCE Confucius A teacher's ideas about duty and good government shape China for 2,000 years. 399 BCE Socrates A philosopher is tried in Athens and chooses death over exile.